Skip to main content
Welcome to the University of Lethbridge
  • Library
  • Directory
  • Intranet
  • MyExperience
  • Webmail
  • Bridge
  • Moodle
Study here Give
School of Graduate Studies
Close
  • Future Students
  • Current Students
    • Welcome to ULethbridge!
    • Next steps for new graduate students
    • New Student Checklist
    • Graduate Journey Guide
    • Standards of Professional Conduct
    • Supervisor - Student Guidelines
    • Completer's Documents
    • IP Guidelines
    • Graduate Peer Mentorship Program
  • Funding & Fees
    • Inquiry Form
    • Award Opportunities
    • Tuition & Fees
    • Funding Tips
    • FAQ Funding & Finances
    • Funding Checklist
    • Student Scholarship System Guide
  • Faculty Members
    • Supervisor - Student Guidelines
    • Admit System
    • Medal Nominations
    • GA (Research) Appointments
    • Referee Scholarship System Guide
    • Reviewer Scholarship System Guide
    • Required Training for School of Graduate Studies Members
    • External SGS Membership
  • Professional Development
    • 3MT & Images of Research
    • Individual Development Plan (IDP)
    • Professional Skills
    • Employment opportunities
    • Graduate Peer Mentors at a Glance
  • Policies & Procedures
    • Contents
    • Definitions
    • Students, Supervisors and Committees
    • Thesis Programs
    • Graduation
    • Appendices
    • Departmental / Program Assessment of Comprehensive Knowledge
  • Resources
    • Graduate Mentorship Award
    • Important Documents
    • Governing Principles
    • Thesis/Project Submission
    • GSA Collective Agreement
    • Graduate Program Committees
    • Sample Program Gantt Charts
    • Completer's Documents
    • Western Deans' Agreement
    • Forms
    • Academic Calendar
    • News
    • School of Graduate Studies Portal
  • About Us
    • Contact Information
    • Alumni
    • Postdoctoral Fellowships
  • Library
  • Directory
  • Intranet
  • MyExperience
  • Webmail
  • Bridge
  • Moodle
Study here Give
Policies & Procedures
  • Contents
  • Definitions
  • Students, Supervisors and Committees
    • Registration, course, and degree requirements
    • Graduate Students
    • Supervisors
    • Committees
    • Progress and Standing Reports
  • Thesis Programs
    • Thesis/Project Proposal
    • Comprehensive Exam
    • Thesis
    • Thesis, Project and Capstone format regulations
    • Thesis Defence
  • Graduation
  • Appendices
    • Master of Counselling Master of Education
    • Master of Health Services Management
    • Master of Nursing
    • Master of Science (Management)
  • Departmental / Program Assessment of Comprehensive Knowledge
    • Cultural, Social, & Political Thought major
    • Department of Biological Sciences
    • Department of Chemistry & Biochemistry
    • Department of Geography & Environment
    • Department of Mathematics & Computer Science: Computer Science
    • Department of Mathematics & Computer Science: Mathematics
    • Department of Neuroscience
    • Department of Physics & Astronomy
    • Department of Psychology
    • Faculty of Education
    • Faculty of Health Sciences

Physics & Astronomy Comprehensive Examination Guidelines

The PhD Comprehensive Examination Committee (CEC) shall be composed by taking the Department of Physics & Astronomy (DPA) Department Graduate Education Committee (DGEC) along with two members of the Candidate’s Supervisory Committee (SC). The DPA Chair (or co-Chairs) will decide which member of the CEC will act as CEC Chair. Normally this will be the DEGC Chair. The DPA Chair (or co-Chairs) also has the right to add another member of the DPA to the CEC, in an ad hoc manner, to assist with the administering of the general written exam (part 1B below). The general written examination is normally administered and adjudicated by the three active DGEC members plus, optionally, the ad hoc member. If the Candidate’s supervisor is a member of the DGEC then this member is replaced by the DGEC Alternate member.

The other parts of this examination (1A and 2) will be administered and adjudicated by a three-member subset of the CEC composed of two members of the SC (normally including the Supervisor) and one member of the DGEC. All three members will be chosen by the DPA Chair (or co-Chairs) and should be selected to properly match the research area of the Candidate.

Examination Component:

Description:

Written Component

1 - Minimum Written Requirement

  • A - The candidate must complete a thorough, independent review of the scientific literature relevant to their area of research study. A list of five peer-reviewed journal articles must be decided upon, not more than one of which can be authored by the candidate's Supervisor. Some of these articles are expected to be influential reviews, such as one finds in the journal Reviews of Modern Physics. The candidate should get advice on these choices from their SC. After careful study of these articles, the Candidate must write a 9-15 page report (Times New Roman 12 pt font using double spacing). The style need not be too formal: for example, references to figures in any of the journal articles do not require that the figures be reproduced in the report. There is no need to reference articles outside of the ones referred to in the articles. The adjudicators are expected to have also carefully read the five pertinent articles.
  • B - The general comprehensive written component should be completed within the first four months of the candidate’s program, and certainly within 12 months of the start date. (If a rewrite is necessary, it must be completed by the 24-month of the candidate’s program.). One three-hour written exam will be administered with questions taken from the textbook used in Physics 1000, Physics 2000, Physics 2120 and Physics 2130 (e.g. the latest editions of University Physics, Young and Freedman (Pearson), Fundamentals of Physics, Halliday, Resnick and Walker (Wiley), Physics for Scientists and Engineers: A Strategic Approach with Modern Physics, by R. D. Knight (Pearson)), including the classical and quantum/atomic physics sections. The candidate will be allowed formula sheets they devise themselves, three letter-size pages, maximum. The exam will consist of 10 problems from the text, and the candidates will be asked to select and complete eight of them to be graded.

Oral Component

2- Minimum Oral Component

  • The candidate will deliver a 40 to 50-minute departmental colloquium on his or her research topic, within the first twenty-four months of the candidate’s program.
  • Departmental colloquia are open to the public. Preferably, the colloquium will be part of the Department of Physics and Astronomy’s capstone course, Physics 3750 (Contemporary Physics).
  • The colloquium will be followed by a closed session of questions and discussion, lasting one to two hours.

The candidate is advised to consult the SGS Policies and Procedures document for further information (including plagiarism issues) pertaining to the evaluation parameters for PhD Comprehensive Examinations.

Approved by Graduate Council on September 16, 2015.

Related links

  • News
  • Forms for current students
  • Info for future students
  • Apply now

Connect with us

  • Twitter
  • ulethbridgesgs
  • LinkedIn
  • Subscribe to the SGS Newsletter

Graduate Program Advising

  • Find the advisor for your program
  • Contact advising

School of Graduate Studies

  • B610 (University Hall)
  • 403-329-2793
  • sgs@uleth.ca

Students

  • Academic calendar
  • Student Enrolment and Registrar Services
  • Student opportunities
  • Student services
  • Study here

Information for

  • Alumni
  • Donors
  • Visitors and community

Campus

  • Careers at uLethbridge
  • Events
  • Faculty and staff intranet
  • Maps and tours
  • News
Visit the University of Lethbridge Homepage
  • Lethbridge, Alberta, Canada
  • Contact us
  • Calgary Campus
  • Faculty and staff directory

The University is located on traditional Blackfoot Confederacy territory. We honour the Blackfoot people and their traditional ways of knowing in caring for this land, as well as all Aboriginal peoples who have helped shape and continue to strengthen our University community.

©2025 University of Lethbridge | Terms of use